Free Health Care, or is it really BMW's for Bums?

64

By MNichopolis

Can you afford to pay for someone elses luxury car?
Can you afford to pay for someone elses luxury car?

Did you know you could lease a new BMW for around $600 a month? (Even a BMW convertible) That's as much as many peoples health care costs, per month.

But alas, a brand new Beamer is not in the cards for me. After Social Security, unemployment taxes, State and Federal taxes, there's yet another big bite, health insurance. And lo and behold, monthly health care alone (family plan for me) adds up to a little more than the monthly lease payments on a nice new shiny BMW.

That's right, for what many of us are paying for health insurance, we could lease a brand new BMW (and upgrade to the latest model every five years, as the lease on the previous car expired).

The best health care in the world, many say. But it sure is expensive. There's no arguing with that. It's the Ferrari of the worlds health care systems, at BMW prices (literally).

But now we're heading down the road towards universal health care, where everyone in the country gets their own equivalent of a shiny new BMW, whether they can afford it, or not. "It's free", the politicians say with a smile. (Probably because it's hard to keep a straight face while saying that?)

Anyone who's paid their fair share of taxes knows that it's not the government that will be paying for these 40 million or so shiny new BMW's (re-upping the lease every five years). It's us, the taxpayers.

I'm already carrying the payment for my own health care "BMW". And I'm sure It's really going to hurt carrying someone elses payment.

What's really a shame is that my shiny BMW health care (plus the other guys I'll be paying for) will probably end up a lot more like a public subway after the government gets their hands on it.

Now I'm not saying we should do nothing. Health care is just too expensive, virtually no one disagrees with that. But what seems to be much smarter than adding 40 million people to a "too expensive health care system" would be first to make the health care system less expensive, or to provide different levels of service at different prices (offer BMW's AND Chevy's).

Without addressing the cost issues first (and verifying that the cost problem really is "fixed"), we'd end up doing something incredibly stupid (like trying to lease 40 million new BMW's forever).

Speaking of incredibly stupid, there seems to be a trend emerging. Health care, global warming, even the economic crisis... fanatic elements seem to keep screeching about the end of civilization as we know - either the planet will be destroyed in natural disasters, or we'll all die from a lack of medical care, to the economy will collapse us into the stone age --- all if WE DON"T ACT NOW! The fear mongering by the fanatical seems to be a strong trend lately. In this case, it's "Our health care system is in ruins. It must be completely re-structured or it's useless."

Many would argue this is clearly not the case. It's reckless, irresponsible, and politically self-serving (just give everyone everything, get re-elected, and raise taxes - business as usual). Trying to give away BMW's for votes while destroying the factory, is again reckless, irresponsible, and politically self-serving.

For what they're going to charge us taxpayers, we might as well be giving away BMW's to bums.

Well, that's all the time I've got, I've got to head over to the Post Office, and wait in line for a while. (If there's time, I can head over to the Department of Motor Vehicles, and wait even longer in line there, woohoo!)

Comments

jiberish profile image

jiberish 2 years ago

Good Hub, I choose the BMW.

Reality Bytes 2 years ago

Health is wealth. Not a German car.

MNichopolis profile image

MNichopolis Hub Author 2 years ago

Given you're deep "sloganism" RB, I guess you missed the point. Health care (as we've allowed the industry to define it) costs, A LOT.

The question shouldn't be "should we give health care to all", but instead "can we afford to give this kind of health care to all".

If you think we all should have todays type of health care (which absolutely DOES cost as much as a German car per month), then it's likely that you're rich (and don't care about the costs), or you're poor, looking for a handout (that costs taxpayers as much as a new BMW).

But then there's the rest of us, millions of hard working people struggling to pay for their own health care (never mind paying for someone elses).

Sorry if I sound miffed, but simplistic slogans simply obscure the issue. If I took that comment seriously, I'd presume you want us all healthy, by sacrificing our cars (and houses, and electricity, etc, because we spent it all on health care).

Ultimately, we'd have to walk downtown and get on the subway to go to the Doctors (where we'd wait in really long lines).

donotfear profile image

donotfear Level 2 Commenter 2 years ago

Very blunt and to the point. Good insight with a touch of sarcasm.

James A Watkins profile image

James A Watkins Level 8 Commenter 2 years ago

I think it is easy to fix. Tort reform; interstate competition of insurance companies. Privatize Medicaid and Medicare. Get the government out of health care altogether. Thanks for a fine and witty Hub.

MNichopolis profile image

MNichopolis Hub Author 2 years ago

Nice! That would get the payments down to something more like a Chevy. Sounds like the way to go to me James!

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working